Gambling legalization Essay Example for Free

Betting authorization Essay Betting is the demonstration of playing for stakes in the expectation of winning (counting the installment of a cost for an opportunity to win a prize). (Oxford word reference) Many have their own feelings about betting and right now betting isn't lawfully rehearsed here in The Bahamas. â€Å"Such a move would stop an unlawful industry that makes a huge number of dollars a year and which utilizes hundreds; however which contributes little to the general great of the Bahamian individuals. † (The Bahama Journal 2008). There are numerous parts of betting that can in fact be viewed emphatically. â€Å"Gambling comes in numerous structures, remembering wagering for club, courses, games, lotteries, bingo games and even virtual betting on the Internet† (Oddo 2007) Gambling ought to be sure be authorized, in light of the fact that it will support our economy and society from various perspectives. On the off chance that betting is polished it’ll give people with inactive time to burn, something to do and it can likewise support our travel industry. The legitimization of betting here in The Bahamas will prompt an expansion in the Bahamas’ Gross residential Product (GDP), an expansion in work, lastly it can add to our media outlet. The legitimization of betting would be of grave advantage for our Government as it identifies with the Gross Domestic Product In an article titled ‘Legalizing betting in The Bahamas’ composed by Craig Butler his contention for betting was that the Prime Minister Rt. Good Hubert Ingraham ought to authorize betting and put a free organization of evaluators to regulate this new turn of events. â€Å"If betting is to be legitimized then he should make the foundation be set up that will maintain a strategic distance from the unavoidable endeavors at altering and control by cunning people. † (Butler 2008). When this happens the Government will have the option to actualize a burdening framework with our own inner income administration (IRS) so a specific level of the cash I. e. twenty five percent will go to the Government in result more cash would be spent on progressively capital products, which means more school’s will be assembled and more work foundation on our streets will be completed. In America, Statistics show that roughly 92. 27 billion dollars originates from betting on a yearly premise. On the off chance that this equivalent situation would concern us here in The Bahamas that will imply that betting would be good for our income and money segment. Some accept that sanctioning betting would just permit the Government a free portion of the cash, and that offer might be spent on their own needs. They will utilize this cash to buy more vehicles for them to be chauffeured around in, to have more ‘business’ suppers for themselves, and to go through on multi day trips all around the globe and the economy won’t feel a dime of it. They are incompletely right on the grounds that a great many people are utilized to lawmakers being casted a ballot in the House of Assembly and never coming around to visit their constituents, hence they come up short on the trust in accepting that the Government will convey once they begin to get the level of rewards. In any case, they are confused in light of the fact that the Government figures a specific level of cash to go into capital products consistently during the spending plan and the ordinary rate that is saved for training and human services can rise and can be utilize all the more fundamentally. â€Å"But the sanctioning of this propensity won't prompt an exponential ascent in the quantity of card sharks. It will, be that as it may, permit government to finance programs that can positively affect our childhood, for example, public venues, sports and instruction offices. † (Butler 2008) Mr. Head servant makes it obviously clear in his investigation in the Bahama savant that if the Government had the additional subsidizes they would utilize it admirably. For instance, there’s now a framework set up by National Insurance for the jobless. The joblessness advantage pays 100 dollars every week to those jobless and if the Government gets more cash this can to go up. Bahamians will get burdened as well as outsiders too. In this way the entirety of the outsiders that are here now utilizing our gambling clubs and returning with all the fixings, would need to leave that twenty five percent charge expense for the administration. Legitimizing betting would likewise prompt a lessening in the joblessness rate. In an article entitled ‘Gambling Entertainment’, it expresses that â€Å"The huge level of work gave by the Gambling business, including the land based club just as the Online gambling clubs, puts betting industry on the highest point of society diagram straight away. † Having betting legitimized would consequently imply that work will increment. At present Gambling is in the ‘underground economy’ mark with regards to figuring the joblessness rate. Since it’s unlawful laborers are viewed as utilized, anyway lawfully they’re considered jobless with regards to the joblessness rate. In an article composed by Olivia Saunders, Saunders delineated the joblessness rate in a chart that indicated a joblessness pace of 7. 8 percent. Out of this 7. 8 percent tally are the individuals that are as of now directly working for number houses, on the off chance that we legitimize betting that rate would consequently diminish. Many are persuade that sanctioning betting won’t decline the joblessness rate, on the grounds that there are as of now a significant measure of lottery houses opened as of now and there are as yet numerous jobless, it’s outlandish for this to support our jobless, and regardless of whether it does, it won’t totally deal with the issue. They are in part right in light of the fact that legitimizing betting won’t lead to a total decrease in the joblessness rate, and it won’t have the option to utilize everybody without work, anyway they are confused in light of the fact that it will help enormously. Authorizing betting implies that more lotto shops will have the option to open, in Nassau as well as on the family islands which will pull in more travelers. In this way they’ll need more staff, this will likewise prompt more gambling clubs and more individuals will be employed in various viewpoints. For instance they’ll need cleaners, clerks, roadster and entertainers. The genuine truth is there are various perspectives in our economy that adds to the joblessness rate both expanding and diminishing and this rate can never be consistent. Anyway once betting is authorized and there are more scenes opened then it’s a need to recruit individuals to work in them, and these individuals will at that point check towards the joblessness rate and it’ll then abatement. At long last the legitimization of betting can be utilized as a game and a type of amusement. The main type of betting isn't buying numbers from the lotto shops as certain Bahamians are caught unaware to accepting, anyway it is additionally a game. There was before a pony hustling setting that was utilized as a game here in 1976 yet needed to leave since betting wasn’t lawful. Authorizing betting would permit this type of amusement to by and by be rehearsed. In a diary named ‘Gambling The expense of our future,’ it demonstrates that ‘Those who partake in betting exercises do so willfully and, consequently, get inherent advantages from their utilization. Moreover, if customers are betting for amusement purposes, they are buying betting similarly as they would buy tickets for the film or an ensemble. † (Basham, White). This announcement raises an astute contention since betting is in reality a hazard anyway this hazard is on a similar degree of purchasing a film ticket and you’re not certain if the film will play or an orchestra and you’re not certain if you’ll appreciate it. Rivals accept that having betting as sports can just prompt increasingly money related issues for an unsteady budgetary home. They may contend that betting is an addictive game and a few families aren’t prepared for the strain that this dependence involves, and a few people might be happy to successfully fulfill this compulsion like submit burglary. Betting dependence is additionally alluded to as urgent betting or neurotic betting. Clinical Author Roxanne Dryden-Edwards raise a significant point in her article ‘Gambling Addiction’ expressing that â€Å"The number of individuals who bet socially meet all requirements for being determined to have a betting fixation go from 2%-5%, in this manner influencing a huge number of individuals in the United States alone. † (Dryden-Edwards) Some may discuss that If The Bahamas populace is just 316,000 contrasted with the United States, at that point our rate will be progressively destructive if betting is practice. Be that as it may, they are confused on the grounds that this diversion and game may not be addictive yet generally fun and energizing and a decent family occasion for generally, despite the fact that there might be some rotten ones the masters may exceed the cons. The genuine truth is that nearly all that we do as a type of gaming exercise is pleasurable and having more open doors will make betting progressively agreeable. The Government can likewise execute a framework with the goal that card sharks that build up the enslavement can be completely dealt with and get mental assistance called Gamblers Anonymous’ (GA). As indicated by the 12 stage recuperation program insights â€Å"Of those in their fourth month of AA meeting participation (I. e. have remained past 90-days) 56% will even now be going to AA toward the finish of that year. † (Holding all others steady if this framework is rehearsed here with addicts treatment will be valuable. Taking everything into account, betting can add to our economy altogether. Many feel as if betting will cause more mischief than anything, be that as it may if it’s rehearsed effectively and everybody withstand to the laws that would be set up, betting will be something other than a simple method to win a generous measure of cash itâ�

GLOBAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT DISCUSSION QUESTIONS 1- Essay

Worldwide BUSINESS MANAGEMENT DISCUSSION QUESTIONS 1- - Essay Example Another significant part of global business is that the impulses of the current occasions require flexibility in the work belief system and working, subsequently making it basic that new aptitudes and techniques are advanced to address the developing difficulties with productivity and unrivaled capability. Goldberg accurately deciphers advanced education and says, ‘academic believing is ground-breaking and usable over significant time-frame frames’ (1996). The investigation would give the experts more extensive points of view of the changing standards of the business condition and help encourage better choices to address the rising difficulties in the elements of new business conditions. One can along these lines, presume that the examination in global business would consistently fill in as worth expansion to any workplace. Charles Hill’s attestation that ‘Countries have diverse political, financial, and lawful systems†¦ All these distinctions can and do have significant ramifications for the act of worldwide business’ (Hill, 2004) is totally right. In the quickly changing condition of globalization, the organizations have become progressively serious subsequently making it required for them, just as for the working power to turn out to be increasingly adaptable and quickly adjust to the changing innovations and workplaces. Another perspective that has developed because of globalization is that of expanded portability that requires the regularly expanding requirement for adaptability of time and spot particularly when the business is spread over the various nations. The non advertise factors have immediate and backhanded effect on the general execution and activity of the firm. ‘These are portrayed by 4Is: issues, foundations, interests and information’ (Baron, p2, 1995). Comprehensively they are the socio-world of politics inside which the firm needs to work. The job of government guidelines and political elements consolidated

The Recency Effect in Psychology

The Recency Effect in Psychology Theories Cognitive Psychology Print What Is the Recency Effect? By Kendra Cherry facebook twitter Kendra Cherry, MS, is an author, educational consultant, and speaker focused on helping students learn about psychology. Learn about our editorial policy Kendra Cherry Updated on April 23, 2019 More in Theories Cognitive Psychology Behavioral Psychology Developmental Psychology Personality Psychology Social Psychology Biological Psychology Psychosocial Psychology In This Article Table of Contents Expand Overview How It Works Examples Why It Occurs Influences Impact on Learning View All Back To Top The recency effect is the tendency to remember the most recently presented information best. For example, if you are trying to memorize a list of items, the recency effect means you are more likely to recall the items from the list that you studied last. This is one component of the serial position effect, a phenomenon in which the position of items on a list influences how well those items are recalled. Overview The serial position effect was first discovered by the psychologist Hermann Ebbinghaus during his memory experiments. He observed that the ability to accurately recall items from a list was dependent upon the location of the item on that list. Items found at the end of the list that are learned most recently are recalled best (the recency effect), while the first few items are also recalled better than those found in the middle (the primacy effect). You have probably experienced this effect many times when you try to learn something new. After learning the information, imagine that you are immediately given a test covering material to see how much you have retained. What information do you think you will remember the best? Chances are that you will have pretty good recall of the things that you learned last or the most recently. You also likely have good recall of the first few things that you learned. It is that information in the middle of your learning session that you are the most likely to struggle with. The recency effect can tell us a bit about how memory works. You can also find ways to maximize your memory by better understanding how and why this effect takes place. Human Memory How It Works The recency effect is dependent upon short-term memory. This type of memory, also known as active or primary memory, is the ability to hold a relatively small amount of memory in the mind for a brief period of time. This information is held and kept active for use, but it is not manipulated. Briefly storing a phone number someone just recited to you for long enough to dial it is a good example of short-term memory. Short-term memory is limited in terms of both capacity and duration. Most information in short-term memory only lasts between 20 and 30 seconds without active maintenance or rehearsal. Approximately four pieces of information can be held in short-term memory for a brief period. Perhaps not surprisingly, delaying recall after hearing a list of items has a dramatic impact on the recency effect. A very long delay between learning items and recalling will often completely eliminate this effect. In other words, the recency effect may occur because you are able to easily remember those items that are still being briefly stored in your short-term memory. If you do not rehearse that information, however, it will quickly be lost and fade from memory. Examples The recency effect can play a role in many different aspects of daily life. For instance, say you are trying to recall items from your shopping list, which you accidentally left at home. You are easily able to remember the last few things you wrote down, but you can’t seem to recall any of the items in the middle of your list. Or, the waiter at a restaurant lists a number of different specials. When you are ready to order, you can only recall the last two options that he mentioned. Another example is as follows: as you are researching a new product you are interested in buying, you’re most likely to pay attention to your first impressions and the last thing you heard about it. If the first thing you hear and the last thing you hear are positive, you are more likely to buy itâ€"even if your research revealed negative information between those two times. Marketers take advantage of the recency effect by ensuring the beginning and ends of ads are positive and appealing. Finally, you have an easier time recalling events from your immediate past than you do things from the distant past. For example, while you might have little trouble remembering what you had for breakfast this morning, recalling what you ate two weeks ago would be much more difficult (or even impossible). Why It Occurs Both the recency and primacy effects are likely the result of memory processes. There are a few explanations for why the recency effect occurs. One is that the most recent information is still present in active memory. When testing is conducted immediately after learning, any information that was learned last may still be actively held in short-term memory. This increases the accuracy of recall. Another explanation is that temporal cues may also help improve recall of the most recently learned information. If a person rehearses a list and is then tested immediately, temporal context can help cue the recall of the information. Influences There are also factors that can impact the strength and likelihood of the recency effect occurring. Factors that can influence the occurrence of the recency effect include: Task Factors: This refers to the task itself as well as how the information is processed. The length of the information presented and how it is presented can influence the recency effect. If you were presented a very short list of words, for instance, you might find it easy to recall all the items, essentially eliminating the recency effect. A very long list of terms, on the other hand, would be much more likely to produce recency effects.Processing: How you attend to and process the information as it is presented can also affect how it is recalled.Time: If a long period of time lapses between the presentation and rehearsal of the information and recall, the recency effect is dramatically reduced or even eliminated altogether.Intervening Tasks: Interference can occur if another task or information is presented after the first task. Research has found that if the distracting task takes longer than 15 to 30 seconds, it will eliminate recency effects when trying to recall the original i nformation. Impact on Learning As you might imagine, the recency effect can play an important role in the learning process. When you are learning new information, you are most likely to remember the things that you study first (the primacy effect) as well as those things you study last (the recency effect). This means that when tested on the material, you are more likely to forget the things that were learned in the middle. However, there are things that you can do to adapt your study sessions to take advantage of these memory phenomena. As you structure your study time, realize that the period at the beginning and the period at the end are your prime learning times. Try the following steps: Focus on the most important information at the beginning to take advantage of the primacy effect. This might involve reviewing important terminology or learning new information.Use the middle of your learning time to read through old material you have already learned. This period is essentially downtime, but it can be useful for reviewing.Spend the last part of your study session reviewing what you have already learned. This can involve rehearsing those important terms or going over your newly learned material. Doing this will help cement newly learned information into your memory and minimize the chances or forgetting the things you learned in the middle of your study session. Teachers can also take advantage of the recency effect in how they structure classroom time. The first part of the class should focus on important information. This means skipping over things like basic administrative tasks such as taking attendance and meet-and-greet icebreakers. The middle section of class might involve a brief break where these formalities might be better attended to. Finally, those last 10 to 20 minutes of the class should focus on circling back to the most important concepts. A Word From Verywell The recency effect will play a role in what you learn and recall, but there are things you can do to maximize your memory. Taking steps like breaking up study sessions into shorter periods can help. Spend the last few moments that you focus on something to review the most important details. Finally, if you want something you say to stand out in someone’s mind, make sure you convey the most important information right at the end. This can apply to your daily conversations, or when you are trying to persuade someone to see things your way, or even during job interviews. First impressions are also critical, but thanks to the recency effect, your parting words can be just as powerful. What Is Interference?

An Overview Of American Higher Education - 838 Words

An Overview of American Higher Education (Baum, 2013) focuses on the evolving definition of a â€Å"college† over the past fifty years. Over this time period, colleges have made changes from focusing on academia discipline to job preparation (Baum, 2013). The expected length of time to obtain a college degree as change as well. The term college encompasses four-year tracks, community colleges, certificate programs and half-time attendance, where a degree can be achieved at your own pace. In the 1960s America’s competitive edge was declining on a national scale and this encouraged a push for a more educated America. Furthermore, the expanding variety of post-secondary education opportunities grew from the idea that access to higher education should be more available, finically and geographically, to the population (Baum, 2013). The federal government decided to become more involved with growing access to higher education through financial programs. They believed making c ollege more affordable increased access to students (Baum, 2013). Their decision made grants, scholarships, and other forms of aid more available to students pursing education after high school. Thus, putting accessibility and affordability at a higher priority than quality of education. Financial assistant programs included a Pell Grant fund and state-funded programs (Baum, 2013). With the increased accessibility, traditionally minoritized and underrepresented populations on campus, specifically female studentsShow MoreRelatedAffirmative Action in Universities728 Words   |  3 Pagessociologists shows that of the students with a 3.2-3.39 GPA applied to medical school, â€Å"Asian Americans had an acceptance rate of 7.7%, while African Americans had a 67.3% acceptance rate† (Espenshade, Radford). While this supports minorities, 1st and 2nd generation Asian Americans are often left with the worst disadvantage. This clearly shows that Kennedy’s mandate is too strong to regulate the nation’s education system. The best way to enforce affirmative action is to set new guidelines that are moreRead MoreThe Objectives of Affirmative Action Policies Essay1039 Words   |  5 Pagesgroups in our society (Affirmative Action: Overview.). These policies usually focus on education and employment (Affirmative Action: Overview.). When it comes to college level education, affirmative action usually mentions admission protocols that give equal admittance to education for groups that were discriminated against throughout history (Affirmative Action: Overview.). These groups include women, and minorities (Affirmative Action: Overview.). Affirmative action came as a result of theRead MoreThe Cost Of Post Secondary School Education1176 Words   |  5 PagesIntroduction In the recent past, the cost of post-secondary school education has rapidly risen in America. An adjustment of the financial aid that comes from both state and federal governments indicates that the cost of university or college education has surpassed that of health care and even inflation (Casselman, 2012). Some of the facets that have led to the increasing costs are state and federal revenue shortfalls and wrong use of cost offsetting. A recent article published in the Wall StreetRead MoreQuality of High School Education1097 Words   |  5 PagesIn America, teenagers are taught to not question or object what is going on in the world. The schools take away their First Amendment rights by not allowing teens to have free speech and voice their beliefs and opinions. The education given to them is censored and limited, not allowing them to see and know the truths behind everything. By doing this, teenagers are being raised to grow up blind like the current generation of adults. The pe ople of America are failing to see the country as it trulyRead More Philosophical And Ideological Perspectives In Education Essay examples784 Words   |  4 Pages Philosophical And Ideological Perspectives In Education Introduction The Second Edition of Philosophical and Ideological Perspectives in Education continue to examine the major schools of philosophy of education through the systems approach. It also considers the relationship of education to major ideologies such as Liberalism, Conservativism, and Marxism. It analyzes the impact of philosophy and ideology on educational theory and practice by examining such theories as Essentialism, PerennialismRead MoreComparison of Turkey and United States Higher Education Essay864 Words   |  4 PagesComparison of Turkey and United States Higher Education Introduction The higher education provided by the United States resembles the structure of the undergraduate college in the United Kingdom, and the research university in German. Turkey’s system of higher education is a product of a long struggle that the country has gone through after proclamation of the country. The character of the higher education in the United States bases its belief from the American people driving the ideals of JeffersonRead MoreTitle Ix741 Words   |  3 PagesTitle IX is a law that states, No person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance... —United States Code Section 20. There are most definitely people that would oppose this law, but most can agree. There should not be discrimination to women, and there shouldn’t have been from the start. Title IX provides women fr eedomRead MoreHistory And Politics Of Education1301 Words   |  6 PagesDemographics of Education Education is a fundamental aspect of society in the United States of America. In order to comprehend how the current education system is at its present state, one must observe the major factors that have affected the education system. Demographics are leaving an everlasting imprint on U.S. education, spanning back to the late nineteenth century at Harvard University (Du Bois 364). According to Norman Eng (Adjunct Assistant Professor at Brooklyn College and education researcher/writerRead MoreThe No Child Left Behind1693 Words   |  7 Pagesfocus on the education of its citizens. The country’s government allots sufficient funding for its education, thus the country is considered the number one nation that spends on per student than any other nation in in the world. With the high price of education and the high cost of funding, the country aims to ensure that all public schools in all states achieve quality education. The â€Å"No Child Left Behind† Act is Americaâ⠂¬â„¢s law that expanded the role of the federal government in education reform, particularlyRead MoreTennessees Department Of Corrections Case Study769 Words   |  4 PagesParker (â€Å"Department Overview†, n.d.). One of the first to be fully accredited through the American Correctional Association (ACA), this department is recognized as a top tier program that others strive to be (â€Å"Department Overview†, n.d.). In 2012, TDOC put a new priority on its probation, parole, and community corrections programs. There is a precedence to ensure that not only are offenders in these programs supervised, but also that supervision is successful (â€Å"Department Overview†, n.d.). Tennessee

Essay On Artificial Intelligence Regulation - 1541 Words

Orion Humphrey Katherine Pack ENGL 1101 22 October 2017 Artificial Intelligence Regulation Artificial intelligence, or AI, is not necessarily a new concept but hasn’t been remotely possible up until a few years ago. It’s recently been a hot topic among the tech community, religious folk, and really, the rest of the world. While in its infancy, AI has the potential to be dangerous and needs to be regulated. Artificial intelligence is something that’s taboo to a lot of people. They wonder whether it’s ethical or right to create life out of nothing. If you’re religious, you might think that God should be the only one to bring life into this world. This is a very small scenario compared to the grand scheme of things that have to do with AI.†¦show more content†¦According to a study by Ball State University, â€Å"An estimated 5 million U.S. factory jobs have evaporated since 2000 and most of those (88%) were lost to increased productivity due to automation†¦Ã¢â‚¬  (Darrow) This is just due to automation and if you incorporate machine learning artificial intelligence, it will take over even more jobs. â€Å"†¦a recent report by consultancy PricewaterhouseCoopers estimates that 38% of U.S. jobs have a ‘high risk’ of being wiped out by automation by 2030.† (Darrow) At the rate technology is increasing and quantum computers just waiting to be released for public use, it’s very probable that a lot of people will lose their jobs. Quantum computers are at this time already 100 million times faster than regular ones (Nield)and there will be no human on earth that can compete with that. An example of this is Goldman Sachs who at the turn of the century were using 600 traders to buy and sell stocks. As of February, 2017, they were down to two, while everyone else had been replaced with automated computer systems. (Byrnes) While some are not so severe, situations like this can destabilize the entire economy. A U.K. research firm states, †Ã ¢â‚¬ ¦nearly 45 percent of the revenue from cash equities trading comes from electronic trades†¦Ã¢â‚¬  (Byrnes) When it’s useless to have people making the trades and only to maintain the machines that do them, it will be a race to get the fastest and smartest computer toShow MoreRelatedCyber Crime Id Theft And Credit Fraud1411 Words   |  6 Pagestechnology, and also expect technologies to continue their concrescence to new more powerful appliances with new features. Since the new technologies/features are on the increase via â€Å"accelerating returns† (Kurzweil, 2001), there is a concern within this essay and an ever increasing global population in the context of privacy, laws and ethical considerations. If it were not hiding under a rock the last several years that would have seen the random outlier news stories. TV discussions about cyber-crime IDRead MoreEnglish For Engineering : Assignment1664 Words   |  7 PagesSTUDENT NAME Tianyuan LI STUDENT NUMBER: 1441959 UNIT CODE: LANG 10003 UNIT TITLE: English for Engineering UNIT TUTOR: Claire Brett TITLE OF ASSIGNMENT: Coursework: Essay WORD COUNT DATE SUBMITTED 22/03/2015 I confirm that this assignment is all my own work and that all source material has been acknowledged appropriately. I can also confirm that I have kept a copy of this assignment. I give permission for my work to be used for future academic purposes. Please tick if you do not wish this. Read MoreThe Controversy Over Genetic Engineering1460 Words   |  6 Pagesunderstandable instances of the implications of this new technology. McKibben’s daughter if created with the â€Å"smart genes†, by Pinker’s standards, just because you change the genes does not mean the daughter is smart because many factors go into intelligence level. Coupled with Mckibben’s beliefs that if the daughter was made smarter, with the rapid rate genetic technology grows she would be outdated and viewed as the standard. Medical technologies have expanded exponentially by doctors and scientistRead MoreThe Impact Of Technology On The Legal Profession Essay2073 Words   |  9 Pages it could potentially change the current legal framework and question the role of lawyers themselves. There are also issues in relation to the protection of clients through data protection, confidentiality and accountability to look out for. This essay will focus on four main points. Firstly, it will discuss the overall impact of technology on the legal profession, while discussing the potential and feared threat of this. Secondly, exploring the lawyer’s responsibility to offer quality and properRead MoreThe Increasing Adoption Of Digital Technologies Essay1891 Words   |  8 Pagesit could potentially change the current legal framework and question the role of lawyers themselves. There are also issues relating more to the protection of clients through data protection, confidentiality and accountability to look out for. This essay will focus on three main points. Firstly, discuss the overall impact of technology on the legal professions, while discussing the perceived threat of this. Secondly, exploring the lawyer’s responsibility to offer quality and proper service and relatingRead More The Pros and Cons of Human Cloning Essay3781 Words   |  16 Pagesthan on any real undesirable consequences. On balance, human cloning would have overwhelming advantages if regulated in a reasonable way. A comprehensive ban on human cloning by a misinformed public would be a sorry episode in human history. This essay will discuss both the advantages and the alleged negative consequences of human cloning. What is a Human Clone? A human clone is really just a time-delayed identical twin of another person. Science fiction novels and movies have givenRead More`` Why Look At Animals `` By John Berger, Clifford, And Artists1869 Words   |  8 Pagesmarginalized both physically and culturally is supported by Descartes’ theory of dualism and the ultimate domestication of animals that leads to their decline. Descartes thought the animal was just a machine without consciousness or thought. In Berger’s, essay â€Å"Why Look at Animals?† he states: â€Å"They belonged there and here. Likewise, they were mortal and immortal...They were subjected and worshipped, bred and sacrificed† (p.4-5). Berger reveals the dualism in our historical relationship with animals. ParadoxicallyRead MoreThe Use Of Ivf And Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis ( Pgd ) Essay2306 Words   |  10 Pagesfunded. Currently, it can only be used for medical reasons, but one of the concerns raised about the technology is that it could potentially be used to select for or against any trait with a genetic origin, such as aspects of physical appearance or intelligence. 1 There are generally five main groups of patients that constitute the demand for such technology. These include those screening for inherited genetic disorders, carriers of chromosomal translocations, female patients undergoing IVF who are approximatelyRead MoreSwot Analysis : Marketing Planning Process1987 Words   |  8 PagesIntroduction This essay will critically evaluate the contribution that SWOT framework has brought to the marketing planning process. The essay will firstly explain the importance of SWOT used as an analysis tool in the field of marketing and concisely introduce the definition of SWOT along with the case of Coca Cola Company as an example. Next, the disadvantages and advantages of SWOT framework will be discussed in order to realize how the model was used in reality and theoretically. After that,Read More The One Child Policy and Gender Inequality1955 Words   |  8 Pagesof citizens are classified by ethnics and occupations to fit the specific regulations of compensations and punishments to prevent them from having a second child (Li, J., Cooney, R, S. 1993). This proposal eventually triggered a profound introspection which chronically melted patriarchal cultures. The broad topic of how government’s decisions altered social norms is discussed within five sociological studies in my essay in allusion to the impacts of One Child policy on gender inequality. Key

Business Ethics of Google in China Free Essays

string(84) " expanded into many other countries and now hosts over 150 country website domains\." â€Å"The Great Firewall† Prepared by Kristina Wilson, Yaneli Ramos, and Daniel Harvey under the supervision of Professor Wayne Norman (edited by Professor Chris MacDonald) In early 2006, search-engine giant Google struck a deal with the People’s Republic of China and launched Google. cn, a version of its search engine run by the company from within China. Launching Google. We will write a custom essay sample on Business Ethics of Google in China or any similar topic only for you Order Now cn required Google to operate as an official Internet Service Provider (ISP) in China, a country whose Communist government requires all ISPs to selfcensor, removing content that is considered illegal from search results. From a financial perspective, China represented for Google a dynamic and fast-growing, though increasingly competitive, market. Google’s decision to self-censor Google. cn attracted significant ethical criticism at the time. The company’s motto is â€Å"Don’t Be Evil,† and prior to entering China, Google had successfully set itself apart from other technology giants, becoming a company trusted by millions of users to protect and store their personal information.The choice to accept self-censorship, and the discussion and debate generated by this choice, forced Google to re-examine itself as a company and forced the international community to reconsider the implications of censorship. This case was prepared as the basis for class discussion rather than to illustrate either the effective or ineffective handling of an administrative situation. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution – Noncommercial – No Derivative Works 3. 0 Unported License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons. org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3. /. You may reproduce this work for non-commercial use if you use the entire document and attribute the source: The Kenan Institute for Ethics at Duke University. Case Studies in Ethics dukeethics. org â€Å"While removing search results is inconsistent with Google’s mission, providing no information (or a heavily degraded user experience that amounts to no information) is more inconsistent with our mission. † – Google senior policy counsel Andrew McLaughlin. †1 Introduction In early 2006, search-engine giant Google struck a deal with the People’s Republic of China and launched Google. n, a version of its search engine run by the company from within China. Launching Google. cn required Google to operate as an of? cial Internet Service Provider (ISP) in China, a country whose Communist government requires all ISPs to self-censor, removing content that is considered illegal from search results. Such censored content ranges from political subjects such as â€Å"democracy† and â€Å"Tibet,† to religious subjects such as â€Å"Falun Gong† (a spiritual movement banned by the government) and â€Å"the Dalai Lama,† to social subjects like â€Å"pornography. By choosing to launch Google. cn, Google seemed to be implying that its mission and values could be consistent with selfcensorship in China. From a ? nancial perspective, China represented for Google a dynamic and fast-growing, though increasingly competitive, market. With over 105 million users online in early 2006, China’s Internet market was the second in size only to that of the United States, but it still represented only about 8% of the Chinese population. Though Google’s U. S. -based site, Google. om, had been available in China since the site’s inception in 1999, service was slow and unreliable due to extensive Chinese government censoring of international content. Google’s major U. S. competitors, Yahoo! and Microsoft MSN, had each entered the Chinese market as ISPs years earlier, agreeing to self-censor. In addition, escalating competition from Chinese search engine Baidu. com was quickly eroding Google. com’s Chinese market share: between 2002 and 2007, Baidu. com’s market share increased from a mere 3%2 to a dominant 58%. Google’s decision to self-censor Google. cn attracted signi? cant ethical criticism at the time. The company’s motto is â€Å"Don’t Be Evil,† and prior to entering China, Google had successfully set itself apart from other technology giants, becoming a company trusted by millions of users to protect and store their personal information. However, in early 2006, Google found itself in front of the Committee on International Relations of the U. S. House of Representatives, defending its actions in China side by side with Microsoft, Yahoo! , and Cisco Systems.Google’s choice to accept self-censorship, and the discussion and debate generated by this choice, forced Google to reexamine itself as a company and forced the international community to reconsider the implications of censorship. Google and its Mission History and Services4 Google is the world’s largest search engine. Founded in 1998 by Larry Page and Sergey Brin, two Stanford graduate students, Google began as a college research project. While at Stanford, the founders created an innovative technology that would analyze webpages and retrieve the most pertinent information for any given search query. 2 3 4 Oliver, C Shinal, J. â€Å"Google will censor new China service†. MarketWatch. (January 25, 2006). Thopmpson, C. â€Å"Google’s China Problem (And China’s Google Problem)†. The New York Times Magazine (April 23, 2006): LexisNexis. Duke University Library. 6 Nov. 2007. Liu, J. â€Å"Baidu and Google at logger heads in China; Business Asia by Bloomberg†. International Herald Tribune (July 26, 2007): LexisNexis Duke University Library. 6 Nov. 2007. â€Å"Milestones†. Available from www. google. com. Accessed on November 4, 2007. Case Studies in Ethics 2 ukeethics. org Their innovation caught the attention of their classmates, and of others who knew them, and later on of a few investors. After they generated suf? cient capital from investors, family, and friends who saw potential in their idea, they opened their ? rst of? ce in a garage in Menlo Park, California. This of? ce had a washer and dryer and a hot tub that was emblematic of what today continues to be Google’s laid-back corporate culture. Now the company has moved into the â€Å"Googleplex,† a much larger of? ce in Mountain View, California. As the company grew, so did its range of products and services. Today, not only is Google a search engine, but it is also a mapping service, a translator, an e-mail account, and a blog-hosting service, among many other services. In fact, Google now has over 40 products and features on its website which extend beyond its basic search engine, with many more in development. The company has also expanded into many other countries and now hosts over 150 country website domains. You read "Business Ethics of Google in China" in category "Papers" It is continually growing and expanding and has a solid position as the world’s #1 search engine.It was also named the best company to work for in 2007 by Fortune magazine. Corporate Culture5 Even though their company has expanded considerably, Larry Page and Sergey Brin have apparently managed to maintain some of the same personal, small-company feel that they started off with. Likewise, despite the company’s move into the Googleplex, it still seems to have kept a corporate culture that re? ects its modest beginnings. Employees do not work in cubicles; instead they work in an open space where dogs and large rubber exercise balls are free to roam.They have a health-conscious company chef and host bi-weekly rollerblade hockey games in the parking lot. The founders host weekly â€Å"TGIF† meetings and promote a laid-back culture. The purpose of this is to create an ideal setting for innovative ideas to ? ow freely. The informal atmosphere makes this possible. Google’s internal structure is a standard corporate hierarchy, yet personnel try not to let hierarchy dominate their personal encounters. Everyone performs tasks outside of their specialty and position whenever needed.Core Values and Mission6 Google’s mission statement asserts that â€Å"Google’s mission is to organize the world’s information and make it universally accessible and useful. †7 The core message under the company’s code of conduct is that â€Å"being a Googler means holding yourself to the highest possible standard of ethical business conduct. †8 The company wants to be able to save its users time and frustration by making the information that the user is looking for readily available, without having to sift through tons of useless information.Not only does Google want to provide fast and ef? cient service, but the company also wants to make its information available for everyone who has access to the internet; they want their product to be â€Å"universally accessible. † Also, the company claims not to want to make ethical sacri? ces just in order to incre ase value for shareholders. The company has made it a priority not to sell high placement in search results to anyone and to show only non-? ashy ads that are relevant to the user’s search query. 5 6 7 8 â€Å"The Google Culture†.Available from www. google. com. Accessed on Nov. 4, 2007. â€Å"Our Philosophy†. Available from www. google. com. Accessed on Nov. 4, 2007. â€Å"Company Overview†. Available from www. google. com. Accessed on Nov. 4, 2007. â€Å"Google Code of Conduct†. Available from www. google. com. Accessed on Nov. 4, 2007. Case Studies in Ethics 3 dukeethics. org China, Censorship, and the Golden Shield Project History China has been playing a game of catch-up in recent years, attempting to modernize and become a larger player in the global market.As it attempted, and eventually succeeded in, entering the World Trade Organization, China was forced to open its markets to foreign companies, granting â€Å"unprecedented access to the Chinese market. †9 During this period of increased foreign access, companies within China started demanding more advanced telecommunications, as well as modern infrastructure. The Chinese government agreed that modernization was necessary, and so quickly began to ? nance this modernization, making the nation one of â€Å"the world’s largest consumers of telecommunications equipment. 10 However, China’s acquisition of more modern forms of information technology leads not only to increased trade and communication ? ow out of the country, but into the country as well. The ? ow of information into the country is what concerns China’s Ministry of Public Service (hereafter referred to as MPS), whose responsibility statement says: The responsibilities of public security agencies in China include: the prevention, suppression and investigation of criminal activities; ? ght against terrorist activities; maintenance of social security and order; ? ght against behaviors jeopardizing social order . . security and inspection of public information networks. 11 These responsibilities include policing the expression of certain ideas and the acquisiti on of sensitive information. As Collings notes, In February 1996, all private subscribers to Chinanet, the main Internet service provider, run by the state telecommunications monopoly, were required to register with the Public Security Bureau, provide the government with detailed personal information about themselves, and sign a pledge not to â€Å"read, copy or disseminate information that threatens state security. . . . In addition to the state-run Chinanet, all Internet service providers were required to take steps to ? lter out anything deemed harmful. 12 As part of their effort to keep up with the more advanced information networks being put in place, â€Å"Chinese authorities are keen to acquire new technologies that will serve to increase their surveillance capabilities. †13 As the new millennium began, the MPS started to implement these new technologies in its censorship activities, using them to restrict access to ideas and information that are outlawed in China.The Golden Shield Project In early 2000, the MPS introduced its new system, the Golden Shield project, which aimed to use state-of-the-art technology as a means of more effectively policing the Chinese people. Although this technology is used to monitor everything from video to voice to Internet traf? c, controlling the ? ow of information over the Internet is the focus of this case. 9 Foreign Policy in Focus. http://www. fpif. org/briefs/vol4/v4n38china. html. Walton, G. (2001). China’s Golden Shield: Corporations and the Development of Surveillance Technology in the People’s Republic of China.Canada: Rights and Democracy. Online: http://www. dd-rd. ca/site/_PDF/publications/globalization/CGS_ENG. PDF 11 Chinese Government’s Of? cial Web Portal. http://www. gov. cn/english/2005-10/02/content_74192. htm. 12 Collings, A. Words of Fire. (New York: New York University Press, 2001). 187. 13 Walton, G. (2001). China’s Golden Shield: Corporations and the Development of Surveillance Technology in the People’s Republic of China. Canada: Rights and Democracy. 10 Case Studies in Ethics 4 dukeethics. org To control the information ? owing over the Internet, the MPS has installed, not ? ewalls exactly,14 but a content? ltering system that works similarly to parental control systems that can block out speci? c material. A story in The New York Times Magazine describes the system this way: There are three main ? ber-optic pipelines in China, giant underground cables that provide Internet access for the public and connect China to the rest of the Internet outside its borders. The Chinese government requires the private-sector companies that run these ? ber-optic networks to specially con? gure â€Å"router† switches at the edge of the network, where signals cross into foreign countries.These routers – some of which are made by Cisco Systems, an American ? rm – serve as China’s new censors. 15 Once the â€Å"? rewall† checks to see if the sites being searched are blacklisted or not, it next utilizes a â€Å"censorship system that uses a keyword blacklist and routers that reach deep into Internet traf? c to ? nd forbidden words or phrases†16 on the sites being searched. This, combined with the fact that those in China know that all of their Internet activities are being monitored, instills fear of imprisonment and limits the in? ux of information that the Chinese government ? ds objectionable. 17 However, the system still only blocks out information coming from outside the country. Peer-to-peer and internal servers are able to avoid the ? lters. Controversy has arisen because the Chinese government’s system fails to prevent access to all content they deem inappropriate. To tighten the net further, and prevent Chinese Internet users from accessing prohibited subject matter available on servers within the country, China has asked providers of Internet services with local out? ts to remove contentious material and to censor their own customers.Additionally, â€Å"[f]or companies inside its borders, the government uses a broad array of penalties and threats to keep content clean. †18 This is required of textmessaging services, search engines, and blogging sites and provides the ultimate way for the Chinese government to block content within the country without having to create more dif? cult-to-implement censorship systems. 19 Backing up all of these censorship mechanisms is the constant threat of imprisonment or other hostile reaction to violations of the censorship laws.This fear keeps both Internet users and se rvice providers vigilant in censoring their own actions within China. In some cases, Internet users even get very pointed reminders that their government is exercising control over their Web-sur? ng habits. Consider the following of? cial announcement: Starting today, when netizens visit all the main portals of Shenzhen city, Guangdong, they will see two cartoon ? gures â€Å"Junghing† and â€Å"Chacha† (Jing Cha = Police). The image of Shenzhen Internet Police will of? cially be online.From now on, when netizens visit websites and web forums of Shenzhen, they will see these two cartoon police images ? oating on their screen20 (see Appendix III). 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Einhorn, B. â€Å"The Great Firewall of China†. BusinessWeek. (September 23, 2002): LexisNexis. Duke University Library. 3 Nov. 2007. Thompson, C. â€Å"Google’s China Problem (And China’s Google Problem)†. The New York Times Magazine. (April 23, 2006). â€Å"Toppling the Great Firewall of China. † eWeek. (September 12, 2007): NA. Academic OneFile. Gale. Duke University Library – Perkins. 3 Nov. 2007.Ibid. Thompson, C. â€Å"Google’s China Problem (And China’s Google Problem)†. The New York Times Magazine. (April 23, 2006). Einhorn, B Elgin, B. â€Å"THE GREAT FIREWALL OF CHINA; How a vast security network and compliant multinationals keep the mainland’s Net under Beijing’s thumb†. BusinessWeek. (January. 23, 2006): LexisNexis. Duke University Library. 3 Nov. 2007. Qiang, X. â€Å"Image of Internet police: JingJing and Chacha online – Hong Yan ( )†. chinadigitaltimes. net. (January 22, 2006). Case Studies in Ethics 5 dukeethics. org Google’s Decision to Launch Google. n The Internet Market in China According to Google’s 2006 projections, the Chinese internet market was expected to grow from 105 million users to 250 million users by 2010. Moreover, in early 2006 there were already 350 million mobile phones in use in China and that number was projected to grow by about 57 million annually. 21 Before choosing to launch Google. cn, Google was already a player in this Chinese market. Since the site’s inception in 1999, U. S. -based Google. com had been available to Chinese users as it had been to users worldwide.Unlike its major U. S. competitors, though, Google did not rush to set up a China-based version of its search engine, and thus to acquiesce to government censorship regulations, as had Yahoo! in 1999, when it established Yahoo! China,22 and Microsoft in 2005, with its establishment of MSN China. 23 Unlike its competitors, Google chose instead to create a version of its search engine capable of understanding character-based languages like Chinese, Japanese, and Korean, which it would run out of its California headquarters. With this U. S. based version of Google. com, the company was able to control an estimated 25% of the Chinese search market by 2002 and to avoid Chinese government censorship completely. 24 By the year 2002, Google. com’s Chinese user base mainly consisted of white collar, pro-Western Chinese businesspeople. 25 However, in the fall of 2002, problems struck. Suddenly, in early September, computer users in China could not access Google. com. The Chinese government had blocked access to the site, and users were instead diverted to rival Chinese search sites. 6 Two weeks later, it again became possible to access Google. com, but government censorship had been heightened, making the search engine far slower and less reliable. 27 Much speculation exists as to why China suddenly chose to shut down and then to stringently censor Google. com. Google Co-founder Sergey Brin and many technology professionals in China believe it was the result of an effort by a Chinese competitor, like the then-new search engine Baidu. com, to gain market share at Google’s expense through pulling strings in the government. 8 The stoppage could also have been due to heightened Internet security in anticipation of a November 2002 shift in political leadership. 29 Whatever the cause, Google was left offering users in China a slow and less-than-satisfactory version of Google. com. Moreover, Baidu. com, now Google’s chief rival in China, began to grow, blossoming from a 3% market share player in 200230 to a 63. 7% market share player in fall 2006, catering in large part to young users looking to download MP3 ? les. 31 Concurrently, Google dropped its market share from 25% in 2002 to 19. % in 2006. 32 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 Schrage, E. , Vice President, Global Communications and Public Affairs, Google Inc. , â€Å"Testimony of Google Inc. before the Subcommittee on Asia and the Paci? c, and the Subcommittee on Africa, Global Human Rights, and International Operations. † (February 15, 2006). Amnesty International. â€Å"Undermining Freedom of Expression in China: The role of Yahoo! , Microsoft, and Google†. (July 2006). Kerner, S. M. â€Å"MSN China Opens its Doors†. InternetNews. com. (May 27, 2005). Thompson, C. Google’s China Problem (And China’s Google Problem)†. The New York Times Magazine. (April 23, 2006). Ibid The New York Times. â€Å"Beijing Blocks Access to Google†. NYT Late Edition, East Coast. (September 4, 2002). Kahn, J. â€Å"China Seems to Re? ne Bid to Restrict Web Access. † The New York Times. (September 14, 2002). Thompson, C. Kahn, J. â€Å"China Seems to Re? ne Bid to Restrict Web Access. † The New York Times. (September 14, 2002). Thompson, C. â€Å"Google’s China Problem (And China’s Google Problem). † The New York Times Magazine (April 23, 2006): LexisNexis. Duke University Library. 6 Nov. 2007. Thompson, C. Fong, Mei. â€Å"Google Builds China ties; Software ? rm deal is part of a move into other services. † The Wall Street Journal. (January 5, 2007). Case Studies in Ethics 6 dukeethics. org Making the Decision to Expand into China Given the commercial potential of the expanding Chinese market and Google’s decrease in Chinese market share between 2002 and 2006, it was imperative for Google to make decisions about whether to escalate operations in China at the price of having to self-censor.To begin the discussion, Google had to make the business opportunity clear. The case was put this way, in February 2006, by Elliot Schrage, Vice President, Global Communications and Public Affairs, Google Inc. : There is no question that, as a matter of business, we want to be active in China. It is a huge, rapidly growing, and enormously important market, and our key competitors are already there. It would be disingenuous to say that we don’t care about that because, of course, we do. We are a business with stockholders, and we want to prosper and grow in a highly competitive world. 3 However, since expanding into China would require Google to self-censor its content on behalf of the communist Chinese government, clearly more was at stake in this decision than potential commercial gain. Co-founder Sergey Brin was born in the Soviet Union and said that â€Å"having felt that kind of oppression, I would never have wanted to compromise in that direction. †34 In order to analyze the potential options, Google developed an analytical framework based on its corporate mission.In the words of Vice President Elliot Schrage: Google’s objective is to make the world’s information accessible to everyone, everywhere, all the time. It is a mission that expresses two fundamental commitments: (a) First, our business commitment to satisfy the interests of users, and by doing so to build a leading company in a highly competitive industry; and (b) Second, our policy conviction that expanding access to information to anyone who wants it will make our world a better, more informed, and freer place. Some governments impose restrictions that make our mission dif? ult to achieve, and this is what we have encountered in China. In such a situation, we have to add to the balance a third fundamental commitment: (c) Be responsive to local conditions35 To understand Google’s decision, it is important to examine the nexus of user interests, the expansion of access to information, and unique local conditions in China. In terms of satisfying user interests, Google prides itself on providing a high-quality user experience. After the Chinese government’s 2002 Internet censorship crackdown, the Google. om experience for a user in China was no longer of high quality. Google. com generated search results extremely slowly because, regardless of the terms searched, each search had to pass through the elaborate â€Å"Great Firewall of China† censoring system. As a site hosted outside of China, and not within the Great Firewall itself, Google. com took a particularly long time to load search results, as compared to search engines hosted in-country like Baidu. com or Yahoo! China. Moreover, 33 34 35 Schrage, E. , Vice President, Global Communications and Public Affairs, Google Inc. â€Å"Testimony of Google Inc. before the Subcommittee on Asia and the Paci? c, and the Subcommittee on Africa, Global Human Rights, and International Operations. † (February 15, 2006). Brin, Sergey, quoted by Hannah Clark. â€Å"The Google Guys in Davos. † Forbes. com. (January 1, 2007). Schrage, E. , Vice President, Global Communications and Public Affairs, Google Inc. , â€Å"Testimony of Google Inc. before the Subcommittee on Asia and the Paci? c, and the Subcommittee on Africa, Global Human Rights, and International Operations. † (February 15, 2006). Bold text included by Mr. Schrage.Case Studies in Ethics 7 dukeethics. org Chinese users found that Google. com was down over 10% of the time; Google News was never available; and Google Images was available only 50% of the time. 36 Another important concern related to user interests is the importance of user privacy. In early 2006, just as Google was planning to launch Google. cn, it became known that Yahoo! China had turned over private user e-mail data to the Chinese government and that this had led to the ten-year, eight-year, and four-year prison sentences of Chinese cyberdissidents Shi Tao, Li Zhi, and Jiang Lijun.In addition, Microsoft had recently shut down the blog of famous Chinese political blogger Michael Anti (a penname for Zhao Jing) at the request of the Chinese government. 37 Clearly any decision made by Google to enter China would have to take into account concerns about user privacy and government surveillance. In terms of expanding access to information, it was Google’s position that due to the poor quality of Google. com for users in China after 2002, Google was in fact not providing the population of China with good access to information. As Google, Inc. Senior Policy Council Andrew McLaughlin put it: Filtering our search results clearly compromises our mission. Failing to offer Google search at all to a ? fth of the world’s population, however, does so far more severely. Whether our critics agree with our decision or not, due to the severe quality problems faced by users trying to access Google. com from within China, this is precisely the choice we believed we faced. 38 Finally, in terms of local conditions, it was important for Google to determine to what extent self-censoring would affect the company’s search results.For users of Google. com in China, searches for censored subject matter, ranging from political subjects like â€Å"democracy† and â€Å"Tibet† to religious subjects like â€Å"Falun Gong† and â€Å"Dalai Lama† to social subjects like â€Å"pornography†, would generate the same list of links as would be generated for a user based in the United States. However, if the user in China tried to open any censored links, either the user’s browser would shut down or the user would be re-directed to a non-censored site.As noted earlier, the â€Å"Great Firewall of China† censorship system is complex and depends largely on intimidation and fear tactics to elicit vigorous self-censorship on both the corporate and the individual level. No of? cial list of banned terms exists. Before laun ching Google. cn, the company estimated that fewer than 2% of all search queries in China would result in pages that would have to be censored. 39 In early 2006, a study by the Berkman Center for Internet and Society at Harvard Law School shed light on the extent and effectiveness of China’s censorship initiatives.According to the Center’s study, the Chinese state was able to block 90% of websites about the â€Å"Tiananmen massacre,† 31% of sites about independence movements in Tibet, and 82% of sites with a derogatory version of the name of former President Jiang Zemin. 40 This study serves to show that as of 2006, Chinese censorship was effective, though not total, and that information was available, though on a limited scale. 36 37 38 39 40 McLaughlin, A. Senior Policy Counsel, Google Inc. , â€Å"Google in China. † The Of? cial Google Blog. (January 27, 2006). Kristof, N. D. â€Å"China’s Cyberdissidents and the Yahoos at Yahoo†.The New York Times. (February 19, 2006) Kristof, N. D. â€Å"China’s Cyberdissidents and the Yahoos at Yahoo†. The New York Times. (February 19, 2006) Schrage, E. , Vice President, Global Communications and Public Affairs, Google Inc. , â€Å"Testimony of Google Inc. before the Subcommittee on Asia and the Paci? c, and the Subcommittee on Africa, Global Human Rights, and International Operations. † (February 15, 2006). Bold text included by Mr. Schrage. Kristof, N. D. â€Å"China’s Cyberdissidents and the Yahoos at Yahoo†. The New York Times. (February 19, 2006) Case Studies in Ethics 8 ukeethics. org Google’s Expansion into China After taking into account user interests, the expansion of access to information, and unique local conditions, Google decided to launch the self-censored Google. cn in January of 2006. In a move toward transparency that distinguishes it from competitors like Baidu. com, Yahoo! , and MSN, Google. cn provides users with a brief message indicating if any pages have been censored from their search results. The message does not inform users what speci? c pages have been censored; it simply lets them know that censorship has occurred. The Washington Post printed a list of the words and phrases that seem to be censored by Google. cn, reporting that these words are the result of Google’s research into what they needed to censor in order to fall under Chinese legal guidelines (see Appendix I). In addition to Google. cn, Google has kept Google. com available to users in China, despite its limited ease of use. Google describes Google. cn as â€Å"an additional service, not a replacement for Google. com in China. The Chineselanguage Google. com will remain open, un? ltered and available to all Internet users worldwide†. 1 To account for user privacy concerns and to avoid having to co-operate with Chinese government investigations of dissidents, as Yahoo! and Microsoft have done, Google chose to refrain from offering products such as Gmail and Blogger (its e-mail and blog services) for Google. cn’s initial release. Amid questions of whether Google would pressure the Chinese government to end its policy of censoring, Google CEO Eric Schmidt said, â€Å"I think it’s arrogant for us to walk into a country where we are just beginning operations and tell that country how to run itself. 42 Clearly, as of early 2006 Google had no plans to shake up the Chinese censorship system beyond making Google. cn censoring transparent to users. Google’s hiring of the extremely accomplished and well-known Kai-Fu Lee to head up Google. cn demonstrates the company’s hope for Google’s presence in the region. Having worked in high positions at Apple and Microsoft and having written a guide for Chinese university students about how to succeed in American business, Lee packs university auditoriums in China wherever he goes to speak. 43 In terms of Google. n’s future, Schmidt expects China to eventually become one of Google’s most important markets, though it only accounts for a small piece of Google’s overall revenue today. In addition, he expects Google’s China research centers to be major sources of innovation for Google, particularly due to the rich talent pool of software engineers coming from Chinese universities. 44 Fallout from Google’s Launching Google. cn Shortly after launching Google. cn in January 2006, Google was called in front of the U. S. House of Representative’s Committee on International Relations, along with fellow U.S. companies Microsoft, Yahoo! , and Cisco Systems, to testify before the Subcommittee on Asia and the Paci? c, and the Subcommittee on Africa, Global Human Rights, and International Operations regarding business operations in China. 45 During the human rights hearing, James A. Leach, an Iowa Republican, asked Google Vice President Elliot Schrage to explain exactly how Google. cn self-censored. Schrage outlined how Google. cn studied competitors’ ? ltering 41 42 43 44 45 Schrage, E. , Vice President, Global Communications and Public Affairs, Google Inc. â€Å"Testimony of Google Inc. before the Subcommittee on Asia and the Paci? c, and the Subcommittee on Africa, Global Human Rights, and International Operations. † (February 15, 2006). Bold text included by Mr. Schrage. Yardley, Jim. â€Å"Google Chief Rejects Putting Pressure on China†. The New York Times. (April 13, 2006) Thompson, C. â€Å"Google’s China Problem (And China’s Google Problem)†. The New York Times Magazine. (April 23, 2006). Thompson, C. â€Å"Google’s China Problem (And China’s Google Problem)†. The New York Times Magazine. (April 23, 2006). Zeller, T. Web Firms Questioned on Dealings in China. † The New York Times. (Feb. 16, 2006). Case Studies in Ethics 9 dukeethics. org methods along with the Chinese government’s method to come up with its own self-censoring system. Leach replied, â€Å"So if this Congress wanted to learn how to censor, we’d go to you – the company that should symbolize the greatest freedom of information in the history of man? †46 Due to this hearing and others – and particularly in light of Yahoo! China and Microsoft MSN’s collusion with the Chinese government, which put three Chinese yberdissidents in jail in Yahoo! ’s case and which shut down a popular political bloggers MSN blog space in Microsoft’s case – in October 2007 the House Foreign Affairs Committee unanimously voted in favor of the Global Online Freedom Act of 2007, which prohibits U. S. companies from disclosing to foreign governments the names and information of speci? c individuals using a given company’s services. 47 The Committee has urged Congress to act with alacrity and pass the Act as s oon as possible. In addition to the U. S. government, Google had to explain its actions to its shareholders.In May 2007, a majority of Google shareholders voted against an anti-censorship proposal which was submitted by the Of? ce of the Comptroller of New York City on behalf of various New York City pension funds which own Google stock (see Appendix II for the full proposal). Google as a company, along with Google’s Board of Directors, recommended stockholders to vote against the proposal. In the words of David Drummond, Senior Vice President for Corporate Development, â€Å"Pulling out of China, shutting down Google. cn, is just not the right thing to do at this point, but that’s exactly what this proposal would do. 48 Google in China Two Years Later In the two years following the launch of Google. cn in January 2006, Google has done well in the Chinese market, remaining second only to Baidu. com in terms of market share. As of the second quarter of 2007, Google had increased its share from 19. 2% to 22. 8% and Baidu. com had fallen from a 63. 7% to a 58. 1% share. 49 In order to penetrate the China search market further, Google aims to make Google. cn as â€Å"Chinese† as possible, both by hiring Chinese employees and by partnering with Chinese technology ? rms.According to CEO Eric Schmidt, one of Google’s â€Å"big projects† during the year 2007 is to grant greater autonomy to Google’s local management in China. Google has tried to distinguish Google. cn as distinctly Chinese by adopting the local Chinese name of â€Å"Guge,† which roughly translates to â€Å"harvest song,† though this name choice has been widely mocked by Chinese users. Overall, Schmidt says, â€Å"As [Google] China gets more established, it will have its own voice, its own expression and, I think, its own look. †50 Already Google has established two research centers, one in Beijing and one in Shanghai. 1 Since launching Google. cn, the company has set up key partnerships with Chinese ? rms that should help Google increase its Chinese market share. In early 2007, Google. cn set up a partnership with China Mobile, the government-owned dominant mobile-phone carrier in China, to manage the ? rm’s mobile Internet search services. 52 Also in early 2007, Google. cn partnered with the Chinese music and video sharing YouTube-like site Xunlei. com. 53 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 Ibid PEN American Center. â€Å"House Foreign Affairs Committee Unanimously Passes Global Online Freedom Act. † (October 23, 2007).Larkin, E. â€Å"Google Shareholders Vote Against Anti-Censorship Proposal†. PC World. (May 10, 2007). Litterick, D. â€Å"Google takes a byte out of the Chinese market†. The Daily Telegraph (London). (August 21, 2007). Dickie, M. â€Å"Google feels upbeat about China market†. Financial Times (London, England). (April 30, 2007) â€Å"Google Adds Local Partner. † Chinadaily. com. en. (August 21, 2007). Poon, T. â€Å"Google to Open Research Center in Shanghai†. The Wall Street Journal. (June 15, 2007). Barboza, D. â€Å"Google Makes Another Investment in the Internet in China†. The New York Times. (January 6, 2007).Barboza, D. â€Å"Google Makes Another Investment in the Internet in China†. The New York Times. (January 6, 2007). Case Studies in Ethics 10 dukeethics. org In April 2007, Google announced a deal with China Telecom, the world’s largest wireless telecommunications and broadband services provider. 54 Finally, in August 2007 Google. cn entered into a partnership with Tianya. com, a Chinese online community. 55 Overall, while Google. cn remains far behind Baidu. com, the company is optimistic. In the words of Schmidt, â€Å"We were late entering the Chinese market and we are catching up.Our investment is working and we will eventually be the leader. †56 54 55 56 Liu, John. â€Å"Google and China Telecom agree on Internet ad sales deal; Business Asia by Bloomberg†. The International Herald Tribune. (April 26, 2007). China Telecom Corporation Limited. http://www. chinatelecom-h. com/eng/corpinfo/overview. htm Accessed Nov. 2007. â€Å"Google Adds Local Partner. † Chinadaily. com. en. (Aug. 21, 2007). Dickie, M. â€Å"Google feels upbeat about China market†. Financial Times (London, England). (April 30, 2007) Case Studies in Ethics 11 dukeethics. org Appendix I: Blacklisted Words57 This is not an of? ial list. It was released by The Washington Post as a list of the words that Google censors on its google. cn site. Names of People Bao Tong Chen Yonglin Cui Yingjie Ding Jiaban Du Zhaoyong Gao Jingyun Gao Zhisheng He Jiadong He Weifang Hu Xingdou Hu Yuehua Hua Guofeng Huang Jingao Jiang Mianheng Jiang Yanyong Jiang Zemin Jiao Guobiao Jin Zhong Li Zhiying Liang Yuncai Liu Jianfeng Liu Junning Liu Xiabobo Nie Shubin Nie Shubin (repeated) Sun Dawu Wang Binyu Wang Lixiong Xu Zhiyong Yang Bin Yang Dongping Yu Jie Zhang Weiying Zhang Xingshu Zhang Zuhua Zhao Yan Zhou Qing Zhu Chenghu Zhu Wenhu 57From The Washington Post, February 18, 2006. Obscenities withheld. Case Studies in Ethics 12 dukeethics. org Zi Yang (in English) Ziyang (in Chinese) Ziyang (in English) zzy (in English, abbreviation for Zhao Ziyang) Chinese Politics 17th party congress Babaoshan Beat the Central Propaganda Department Blast the Central Propaganda Department Block the road and demand back pay Chief of the Finance Bureau Children of high of? cials China liberal (in English) Chinese Communist high of? ials Denounce the C entral Propaganda Department Down with the Central Propaganda Department Impeach Lin Zhao Memorial Award Patriots Alliance Patriots Alliance (abbreviated) Patriots Alliance Web Police chase after and kill police Pollution lawsuit Procedures for dismissing an of? cial Red Terror Set ? res to force people to relocate Sons of high of? cials The Central Propaganda Department is the AIDS of Chinese society Villagers ? ht with weapons Wang Anshi’s reform and the fall of the Northern Song dynasty Speci? c Issues and Events Buy corpses Cadres transferred from the military Cash? esta Cat abuse Changxin Coal Mountain China Youth Daily staff evaluation system Chinese orphanage Chinese Yangshen Yizhi Gong Demobilized soldiers transferred to other industries Dongyang Dongzhou Fetus soup Foot and mouth disease Case Studies in Ethics 13 dukeethics. orgFuzhou pig case Gaoxin Hospital High-speed train petition Hire a killer to murder one’s wife Honghai Bay Horseracing Jinxin Pharmaceut ical Kelemayi Linyi family planning Market access system Mascot Military wages No Friendlies Prosecutor committed suicide Pubu Ravine Shanwei government Suicide of deputy mayor Suicide of Kuerle mayor Swiss University of Finance Taishi village Top ten worst cities Wanzhou Weitan Zhang Chunxian welcomes upervision against corruption Falun Gong Terms related to the banned Falun Gong spiritual movement, including phrases from its â€Å"Nine Commentaries† manifesto against the Communist Party: Chinese Communist Party brutally kills people dajiyuan (in English) Defy the heavens, earth and nature. Mao Zedong Epoch Times Epoch Times (written with a different character) Epoch Times news Web site Evaluate the Chinese Communist Party Evaluate the Chinese Communist Party (abbreviated) falundafa (in English) ? (in English) Fozhan Qianshou Fa Guantong Liangji Fa In the Chinese Communist Party, common standards of humanity don’t exist Li Hongzhi lihongzhi (in English) Master Li ming hui (in English) Mother and daughter accused each other, and students and teachers became enemies New Tynasty TV Station Case Studies in Ethics 14 dukeethics. org Nine Commentaries No. evil cult in the world Obedient citizens under its brutal rule People become brutal in violence, Chinese Communist Party People developed a concept of the Chinese Communist Party, but People who could escape have escaped, and had people to seek refuge with Quit the party Run the opposite direction of the so-called ideals of Communism Shenzhou Jiachifa Spring Festival Gala of the World’s Chinese Steal people’s painstaking work Truth, Compassion, Tolerance Zhenshanren (in English) Overseas Web Sites, Publications and Dissident Groups Century China Foundation China Issues Forum China Renaissance Forum China Society Forum China Spring Chinese Current Affairs Chinese World Forum EastSouthWestNorth Forum EastWestSouthNorth Forum Forum of Wind, Rain and the Divine Land Freedom and Democracy Forum Freedom to Write Award Great China Forum Han Style Huatong Current Affairs Forum Huaxia Digest Huayue Current Affairs Forum Independent Chinese PEN Center J imaoxin Collection Justice Party Forum New Birth Web New Observer Forum North American Freedom Forum reminbao (In English) remingbao (In English) Small Reference Spring and Summer Forum Voice of the People Forum Worldwide Reader Forum You Say I Say Forum Zhengming Forum Case Studies in Ethics 15 dukeethics. org Zhidian Jiangshan Forum Zhongshan Wind and Rain Forum Taiwan Establish Taiwan Country Movement Organization Great President Chen Shui-bian Independent League of Taiwan Youth Independent Taiwan Association New Party Taiwan Freedom League Taiwan Political Discussion Zone Ethnic Minorities East Turkestan East Turkestan (abbreviated) Han-Hui con? cts Henan Zhongmu Hui rebellion Hui village Langcheng Gang Nancheng Gang Nanren Village Tibet independence Xinjiang independence Zhongmu County Tiananmen Square Memoirs of June 4 participants Redress June 4 Tiananmen videotape Tiananmen incident Tiananmen massacre Tiananmen generation World Economic Herald Censorship Cleaning and rectify ing Web sites China’s true content Internet commentator News blockade Case Studies in Ethics 16 dukeethics. org International Indonesia North Korea falls out with China Paris riots Tsunami Other Armageddon Bomb Bug Handmade pistol Nuclear bomb Wiretap Chinese People Tell the Truth Chinese People Justice and Evil China Social Progressive Party Chinese Truth Report Dazhong Zhenren Zhenshi Jingdongriji Night talk of the Forbidden City People’s Inside Information and Truth Case Studies in Ethics 17 dukeethics. org Appendix II: Proposal Number 558 Stockholder Proposal The Of? e of the Comptroller of New York City has advised us that it intends to submit the proposal set forth below for consideration at our annual meeting. It is the custodian and trustee of the New York City Employees’ Retirement System, the New York City Teachers’ Retirement System, the New York City Police Pension Fund, and the New York City Fire Department Pension Fund, and custodian of the New York City Board of Education Retirement System (the â€Å"Funds†), which bene? cially own 486,617 shares of Google’s Class A common stock. The proposal, along with the Funds’ supporting statement, is included verbatim below. The Funds’ request was submitted by Patrick Doherty, The City of New York Of? ce of the Comptroller, 1 Centre Street, New York, New York, 1007-2341.The Funds’ Stockholder Proposal Internet Censorship Whereas, freedom of speech and freedom of the press are fundamental human rights, and free use of the Internet is protected in Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which guarantees freedom to â€Å"receive and impart information and ideas through any media regardless of frontiers†, and Whereas, the rapid provision of full and uncensored information through the Internet has become a major industry in the United States, and one of its major exports, and Whereas, political censorship of the Internet degrades the quality of that service and ultimately threatens the integrity and viability of the industry itself, both in the United States and abroad, and Whereas, some authoritarian foreign governments such as the Governments of Belarus, Burma, China, Cuba, Egypt, Iran, North Korea, Saudi Arabia, Syria, Tunisia, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, and Vietnam block, restrict, and monitor the information their citizens attempt to obtain, and Whereas, technology companies in the United States such as Google, that operate in countries controlled by authoritarian governments have an obligation to comply with the principles of the United Nations Declaration of Human Rights, and Whereas, technology companies in the United States have failed to develop adequate standards by which they can conduct business with authoritarian governments while protecting human rights to freedom of speech and freedom of expression, Therefore, be it resolved, that shareholders request that management institute policies to help protect freedom of access to the Internet which would include the following minimum standards: 1) Data that can identify individual users should not be hosted in Internet restricting countries, where political speech can be treated as a crime b y the legal system. 2) The company will not engage in pro-active censorship. 58 http://investor. google. com/pdf/2007_notice_n_proxy_statement. pdf. Pgs 30-31. Case Studies in Ethics 18 dukeethics. org 3) The company will use all legal means to resist demands for censorship.The company will only comply with such demands if required to do so through legally binding procedures. 4) Users will be clearly informed when the company has acceded to legally binding government requests to ? lter or otherwise censor content that the user is trying to access. 5) Users should be informed about the company’s data retention practices, and the ways in which their data is shared with third parties. 6) The company will document all cases where legally-binding censorship requests have been complied with, and that information will be publicly available. Required Vote Approval of the stockholder proposal requires the af? rmative â€Å"FOR† vote of a majority of the votes cast on the proposal.Unless marked to the contrary, proxies received will be voted â€Å"AGAINST† the stockholder proposal. Recommendation Our board of directors recommends a vote AGAINST the stockholder proposal. Case Studies in Ethics 19 dukeethics. org Appendix III: ChaCha and JingJing59 Cyber Police to Guard all Shenzhen Websites Shenzhen police plan to equip all Shenzhen Websites and electronic bulletin board systems with two virtual policemen icons on the main pages to maintain order in cyber space. People may click the two cartoon policemen to enter the cyber space (http://66110. qzone. qq. com, http://777110. qzone. qq. com ) of two virtual cops and ask questions about information safety. Real policemen will answer their questions immediately.Internet users may also learn information about the Internet laws and regulations and some typical Internet criminal cases from these two virtual policemen. â€Å"The two dummy policemen were made to remind Netizens the Internet is protected by the law. People should pay attention to their behavior when they are sur? ng on the Net,† a senior of? cial of the Shenzhen cyber police told China Youth Daily. 59 â€Å"Cyber Police to Guard All Shenzhen Websites†. Shanghai Daily. (January 5, 2006). Available from http://www. china. org. cn/english/government/154200. htm. Retrieved on November 6, 2007. Case Studies in Ethics 20 dukeethics. org Study Questions 1. Which factors best explain why Google was so successful in the ? rst place?Were any of these conditions for success put in jeopardy by the decision to launch Google. cn? 2. Was Google right to have entered the Chinese market the way it did? Did Google’s mission compel it to create Google. cn? What speci? c aspects of the mission does Google address in making its decision to enter? What other reasons could there have been for entering China? How do Google’s conclusions ? t with its motto, â€Å"Don’t be Evil†? 3. Where is the success of the Chinese censorship system? In other words, what makes their censorship system work so well? Where does Google ? t in to this system? Has Google worked to improve the situation? What more could it do? Case Studies in Ethics 21 dukeethics. org How to cite Business Ethics of Google in China, Papers

Police Discretion and Corruption free essay sample

The Fine Line between Police Discretion and Corruption Abstract In todays law enforcement agencies there Is a fine line between discretion and corruption. Imagine that you are a police officer, you pull over a car that you suspect is driven by someone who has had too much to drink. Upon reaching the window you find that its an old friend from school. Do you take him to jail or do you take him home? Police officers have the power to make this decision.In the world of the officer this could be a case of discretion but in the eye of the public it would most likely it loud be considered corruption. Police corruption Is a major problem for our society. It has been a growing problem since the days of Prohibition. One major concern Is how to separate corruption and discretion. Studies have been taken and the results show that officers have different opinions on what corruption Is and how It should be dealt with. We will write a custom essay sample on Police Discretion and Corruption or any similar topic specifically for you Do Not WasteYour Time HIRE WRITER Only 13.90 / page (Clocker, 2005, p. 02) The surveys were conducted on different departments; in turn different agencies have deferent cultures of integrity so the surveys accuracy could be questioned (p. 102). With the information from the studies we only know that officers have different opinions on what is corruption and what is discretion. The combination of power, authority, and discretion in police work produces great potential for abuse. Police corruption is a complex problem, which has no solution. It is a problem that has and will continue to affect us all, whether we are civilians or law enforcement officers.Police corruption has Increased dramatically with the Illegal cocaine trade, and the officer acting alone or In-groups to steal money from dealer ND/or distribute cocaine themselves. Large groups of corrupt police officers have been caught in New York, New Orleans, Washington, DC, and Los Angels. Corruption within police departments falls into two basic categories: internal corruption, involving relationships among the police within the works of the police department and external corruption, which involves police contact with the public.There are many different forms of corruption; gratuity, involving free meals, free dry cleaning and discounts; bribery, involving the exchange of money or something of value teen the police and wrong doer (this is very common among narcotics officers); theft and Burglary, involving officers stealing property, money and/or drugs from the department; and stealing from people under the influence, who essentially become victims of the police. A new form of police corruption developed in the early sasss and Into the sasss, which Include brutality, delimitation, sexual harassment, corrupt officers start off as honest and idealistic. The career of corruptions begins violation of the laws, involving larger amounts of money and officers initiating corrupt acts. It can be said that power inevitably tends to corrupt, and it is yet to be recognized that, while there is no reason to presume that police officers as individuals are any less fallible than other members of society, people are often shocked and outraged when officers are exposed violating the law. The danger of police corruption could invert the formal goals of the organization and may lead to the use of organizational power to encourage and create crime rather than to deter it.There have been many attempts to put an end to police corruption, with no real success. An attempt to eliminate corruption, by increasing salaries, more training, incentive for education, and t he development of policies that focus directly on factors leading to corruption. Despite many efforts by the police departments to control corruption, it still exists. Police corruption has a very long standing history. Controlling corruption has to come from both the police department and the assistance and support of local community members.Community members should be educated about the negative effects of corruption within the police agency and hat gratuities (most common form of police corruption), is Just the means for future corruption. They should be aware of regulations. Controlling corruption from the departmental level requires an organization with strong leadership. Corruption can take place at any level in the police department, from the patrol officer, to the chief of police. Controlling corruption begins with the chief of police and his attitude. The chief has to make it clear that corruption will not be tolerated. Establishing rules and regulations within the department to insure that all officers conform to certain behavior will help. A proactive integrity test should be in place. All police candidates should be pre-screened (background checks, drug test, alcohol testing), which will help to weed out the bad candidates from future police officer positions. The fight against corruption will be a long battle as the problems of yesterday, still remain today, with little to no improvement.Discretion is defined as the opportunity for law enforcement officers to exercise choice in their daily activities. In most cases this is where corruption starts. An officer sakes a free cup of coffee; next hes taking bribes for simple tickets. Although most of the time it doesnt reach the high level of corruption it does happen. Discretion in law enforcement has always been a hot topic with the police and the community. The community thinks that the police do not use enough discretion and the police think they use too much discretion.In my opinion I believe that the police should be able to use discretion when they can as long as it doesnt cross that fine line into corruption. The police make very hard decisions on a daily basis and you do to want an officer to rush into a decision where he either has to shoot, or has to talk you down. Discretion is a very important tool used by law enforcement. Police discretion designates power or freedom to Judge and decide what needs to be done in a certain situation.When the police get involved in a situation the first thing he does is figure out whether or not the situation should be criminality or if it Just involves some intervention by the police. For instance, if the police arrive at a bar they should arrest the person, or cut them a brake and let them go with a warning. The police may arrive on a scene to assist a woman giving birth; the officer must use discretion and make a quick decision. He may first call an ambulance or he may have to escort her in his car to get there quicker.Police officers have to use discretion on a daily basis. There will never be a way for the police to have a manual on every situation that may occur and what the officer should do in that situation. This is where discretion comes into play for officers, there are Just way too many out of the ordinary situations out there for police officers not to use discretion. Police officers are trained very well but the one thing they cannot teach is when and where to use discretion.Although there are only a small number of corrupt police officers it still has a negative effect on society. Citizens feel that because of the corruption that they cant trust all police officers. In some instances people would rather deal with problems themselves rather than calling on police officers that they feel they cannot trust. Police officers need to ban together and police themselves and get rid of corruption so that citizens can trust whoever shows up in the time of need.